How Do Lawyers Negotiate Settlements? (Guide 2024)

A common way to settle a legal disagreement is through a settlement. As a matter of fact, around 90% of civil cases are settled out of court. In other words, lawyers spend a lot of time trying to reach agreements with their clients.

But how exactly do lawyers talk about settlements? What are the plans and methods they use to help their clients get the best results?

It’s time to take a look behind the scenes at settlement talks in this blog post. We’ll talk about the different steps in the process, the common strategies lawyers use, and the things that can change how a deal goes.

How Settlement Talks Work: The Steps

There are four steps that settlement talks usually go through:

1. Pre-Negotiation

During the pre-negotiation stage, lawyers learn more about the case and figure out what their client’s strengths and flaws are. They also look into the law and the stance of the other side. Setting reasonable goals for the discussion is very important at this stage.

2. Opening Offers

After lawyers have learned a lot about the case, they will make starting offers to each other. Most of the time, these deals are based on how much the lawyer thinks the case is worth in damages. While the beginning offer isn’t always what the lawyer hopes to get in the end, it is a place to start the negotiation process.

3. Bargaining

The back-and-forth between the lawyers really happens during the bargaining stage. There are many ways that lawyers will try to get their clients the best deal. Some of these strategies are:

  • When you anchor, you make a very low starting offer to get the other side to lock in on a higher number.
  • Giving in: Lawyers often give in on small things to get the other side to give in on bigger things.
  • Some lawyers may say they will go to court if they can’t reach a deal, which is called a threat.

4. Settlement Agreement

A settlement agreement will be written if the lawyers can come to an understanding. The terms of the payment will be spelled out in this agreement. It will say how much money will be paid and what other mistakes have been made.

Tricks that lawyers often use

Aside from the strategies listed above, lawyers also use a number of other common strategies when they are negotiating a deal. Some of these are:

  • Building rapport: To make things easier for everyone, lawyers will often try to get along with the other lawyer.
  • Active listening: Lawyers need to be good listeners to understand the other side’s point of view and find places where both sides might agree.
  • Body language: Lawyers can show leadership and confidence through their body language.
  • Silence: Being quiet is sometimes the best way to get the other person to talk.

Things that affect how a negotiation turns out

A settlement discussion can go in a number of different directions, some of which are:

  • How good the case is: The best the case, the more likely it is that the lawyer can arrive at a fair settlement.
  • How ready both sides are to compromise: If both sides are ready to work together, a solution is more likely to be found.
  • The lawyer’s skill and experience: A lawyer with a lot of skill and experience is more likely to be able to get their client a good deal.

How Can I Get the Best Settlement?

There are a few things you can do to improve your chances of getting the best possible result in a legal dispute that you want to settle:

  • Get a good lawyer. A good lawyer will be able to look over your case, bargain on your behalf, and look out for your best interests.
  • Make sure your goals are reasonable. You should know that you might not get everything you want in a deal.
  • Be ready to give in: If you want to reach a deal, you will have to be ready to give in some things.
  • Be patient. Talking about a settlement can take a while. Do not think that you will be able to agree right away.

Why lawyers try to reach agreements

There are a few main reasons why lawyers try to reach deals instead of always taking cases to court:

1. Being efficient and saving money:

  • Getting a deal can often be done much more quickly than going to court, which can take months or even years. This helps everyone out and saves time and money.
  • Lower legal fees: During a trial, legal fees can add up quickly, so settling can make the whole legal case much cheaper.
  • Less stress: Going to court can be stressful and draining on your emotions. Talking about a settlement can be a more peaceful and less upsetting way to settle a disagreement.

2. Control and being able to predict:

  • Results That Are Certain: With a deal, the results are certain, but with a trial, the results are always unknown. This keeps both sides from having to worry about losing in court.
  • Customized Agreements: Settlements can be changed to fit to the wants of both sides. With a court order, this isn’t always possible.
  • Privacy: Settlement talks are usually private, but court cases are open to the public. This could be important for people who want to keep their disagreement between themselves.

3. Strategic Considerations:

  • Making your case stronger: During negotiations, you can get information from the other side that could be useful in court. A settlement offer can also be used to get the other side to agree to a deal.
  • Staying Away from the Unknown: Both sides can stay away from the unknown of a hearing by settling. This can be especially helpful when the law isn’t clear or when the information isn’t strong.
  • Reducing Risks: Going to court comes with the chance of getting a bad ruling. Talking about a settlement can help both sides get something out of the disagreement and lower their risk.

In the end, deciding whether to settle or go to court is a complicated matter that should only be done after talking to your lawyer about each case. You can make the best choice for your case, though, if you know the benefits of settlement talks.

Things personal injury lawyers think about when they’re making settlements

Personal injury lawyers are skilled negotiators who carefully look at a lot of different factors to get their clients the best deal possible. When they make their plans, they keep these things in mind:

1. How Strong the Case Is:

  • Liability: This depends on who was at fault and how much they were to blame. A good case for a settlement is strengthened by strong proof that shows who was negligent and how much they caused the damage.
  • Damages: The amount of physical, mental, and financial harm done has a big effect on the negotiating power. Medical records with lots of details, proof of missed wages, and expert witness testimony all help the case for a lot of money.

2. Financial Aspects:

  • Medical Bills: The amount of money that will be paid for present and future medical bills related to the injury is a very important factor in figuring out the settlement number.
  • Lost Wages: When someone sues for lost wages, the amount of money they lost because of the accident and the chance that they won’t be able to work in the future are both taken into account.
  • Insurance Policy Limits: The at-fault party’s insurance coverage sets the highest amount that can be recovered, which affects the range of possible settlements.

3. Things that affect strategy and psychology:

  • Public Perception: Personal injury cases often have dramatic stories. Lawyers use smart talking to show strong proof and testimonies that the insurance company or jury will understand, which could raise the settlement value.
  • Negotiation Timeline: Having to work quickly can help both sides. Lawyers figure out how important it is to settle quickly and use settlement dates to get the other side to agree to terms.
  • Risk Factors: The unknowns of going to court are weighed against the certainty of a deal. The chance of losing in court or having a case drag on for a long time can make people want to settle, even if the amount is less than what was originally wanted.

4. Client Preferences and Priorities:

  • Financial Needs: The lawyer adjusts the negotiation plan to meet the client’s short- and long-term money needs because of the injury.
  • Emotional Well-being: Long court cases can be hard on the emotions. When lawyers look at settlement deals, they think about how much the client wants to end the case quickly and end the case for good.
  • Personal Control: Letting the client help make big choices, like whether to accept or refuse an offer, shows that the lawyer cares about the client’s wishes and is in line with those wishes.

5. Additional Considerations:

  • Jurisdiction: The laws and past cases of the courts in a certain area can affect the value of personal injury claims and how to negotiate.
  • Prior Case Law: Looking at cases that were similar, with similar injuries and results, can help you come to a good settlement.
  • Expert Opinions: Consulting to medical and financial experts increases the value of the case and gives proof to back up the amount of money being asked for in compensation.

Personal injury lawyers try to get the best outcome for their clients by carefully considering these factors and negotiating with skill and compassion. They do this by seeking fair compensation for their pain and suffering while balancing strategic concerns with client preferences.

How a lawyer Negotiate with the Insurance Company?

Personal injury lawyers use a strategic mix of strategies and arguments when they talk to insurance companies to get their clients the best deal possible. Here are some of the tools they use:

1. Getting Facts and Putting Together a Strong Case:

  • Lawyers carefully gather medical records, police reports, witness statements, and pictures of the accident scene to build a strong case in support of their client’s claim.
  • They may make plans for their client to get more medical exams to find out the full amount of their injuries and any possible long-term effects.
  • Expert Consultations: Talking to medical and financial experts can help the case and provide proof to support the requests for compensation.

2. Getting the talks started:

  • Demand Letter: Lawyers usually start talking to people with a demand letter that explains the facts of the case, gives proof of the client’s claim, and asks for a certain amount of money in pay. This sets the first terms of the negotiation and gives the conversation a place to start.
  • Opening Offer: The insurance company will usually respond with a much cheaper offer, which starts the negotiations that will go back and forth.

3. Strategies and tactics for negotiating:

  • Concessions and Anchoring: Lawyers may make small concessions on purpose to get the insurance company to make bigger ones. They might also use anchoring, which means starting with a high demand to change the end settlement amount.
  • Highlighting Damages: Lawyers stress the injury’s physical, mental, and financial effects on their client, such as medical bills, lost wages, and possible future limitations.
  • Threat of Litigation: This isn’t always used as a bargaining chip, but the insurance company can use the fact that it might have to go to court and pay more fees as a bargaining chip.
  • Effective Communication: It’s very important to have good conversation skills. Lawyers get to know the insurance company reps, listen to their counterarguments, and then use facts and proof to make their client’s case clear.
  • Be patient and persistent, because negotiations can take a long time. Lawyers are patient, persistent, and flexible, and they use offers and counteroffers as a strategy tool to get a good result.

4. Closing the Deal:

  • Evaluating Offers: Lawyers carefully compare settlement offers to what their client wanted in the beginning, the strength of the case, and the possible risks of going to court. They think about the pros and cons of either agreeing to the terms or continuing the talks.
  • Coming to an agreement: Once a good deal is made, a written settlement agreement is made that spells out the agreed-upon amount of money and any other legal terms.

Always keep in mind that each case is different and that negotiation tactics change depending on the situation.

How long do settlements take?

There isn’t a single answer that fits all when it comes to settlement times because they depend on so many things. But I can give you some general rules and things that affect how fast a deal happens:

Timeframes on average:

  • Simple cases: Cases that are easy to understand, like small car accidents where it’s clear who was at fault, may be settled in a few weeks to a few months.
  • Cases that are hard to understand: Cases like medical malpractice that have a lot of proof and expert witnesses can take years to settle.

Common scenarios in which attorneys frequently negotiate settlements:

The great thing about settlements is that they can be used in a lot of different law areas. Here are a few different types of cases where lawyers often arrange settlements:

Personal Injury:

  • Car accidents, including rear-end collisions, hit-and-runs, accidents involving pedestrians, motorbike accidents, and more.
  • Slip and fall accidents: Injuries from falling on someone else’s property due to negligence.
  • Medical malpractice: Negligence by healthcare professionals leading to patient injuries.
  • Product liability: Injuries caused by defective products.

Civil Law:

  • Contract disputes: Breaches of contract agreements, non-payment of debts, etc.
  • Property disputes: Boundary issues, landlord-tenant disagreements, property ownership conflicts.
  • Employment disputes: Wrongful termination, discrimination, unpaid wages, etc.
  • Defamation: Statements or publications damaging someone’s reputation.

Family Law:

  • Divorce: Division of assets, child custody arrangements, alimony payments.
  • Child support: Agreements for financial support of children.
  • Prenuptial agreements: Defining financial rights and obligations before marriage.

Business Law:

  • Commercial disputes: Breach of contract between businesses, intellectual property infringements.
  • Partnership dissolutions: Agreements on dividing assets and liabilities when a business partnership dissolves.
  • Non-compete agreements: Negotiating the terms of post-employment restrictions.

Criminal Law:

  • Plea bargains: Agreements where defendants plead guilty to lesser charges in exchange for lighter sentences.
  • Civil settlements arising from criminal cases: Compensation to victims from defendants charged with crimes.

Environmental Law:

  • Pollution lawsuits: Negotiating clean-up costs and compensation for environmental damage.
  • Resource disputes: Agreements on resource use and conservation between companies and communities.

Keep in mind that this isn’t a complete list. Settlement talks can happen in almost any legal case where people who are at odds with each other want to find a solution outside of court. The choice to settle comes down to the specifics of each case, the parties’ willingness, and the possible benefits of settling instead of going to court.

Some examples of settlements

With case names and numbers, here are some well-known settlements:

Personal Injury:

  • Walter Lack v. FedEx: $22.5 million for a truck driver who suffered brain damage in a collision with a FedEx truck.
  • John and Jane Doe v. Catholic Diocese of Rochester: $14 million for a couple who suffered severe injuries in a car accident caused by a priest.
  • Erin Andrews v. Marriott International: $55 million for a sports reporter who was secretly videotaped in her hotel room.

Product Liability:

  • In re: Vioxx Litigation: Merck & Co. agreed to pay $4.85 billion to settle thousands of lawsuits alleging that its painkiller Vioxx caused heart attacks and strokes.
  • Takata Airbag Recall: Multiple automakers have settled for billions of dollars to compensate victims of defective Takata airbags that caused injuries and deaths.

Medical Malpractice:

  • Kenneth Baum v. New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation: $15 million for a man who suffered brain damage due to medical negligence during a routine procedure.
  • Estate of Michael Jackson v. AEG Live: $134 million to Jackson’s family for his wrongful death caused by the negligence of his doctor, who was hired by AEG Live.

Class Action Lawsuits:

  • Apple iPhone Throttling Settlement: $500 million to compensate consumers for Apple’s practice of slowing down older iPhones.
  • Equifax Data Breach Settlement: Up to $425 million to compensate victims of the massive Equifax data breach in 2017.

Environmental Law:

  • Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill: BP agreed to pay $20.8 billion to settle claims related to the 2010 oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico.
  • Volkswagen Emissions Scandal: Volkswagen paid over $25 billion in settlements for violating environmental regulations by installing software that allowed its vehicles to cheat on emissions tests.

Employment Law:

  • Google Gender Discrimination Settlement: $118 million to settle a class-action lawsuit alleging gender discrimination in pay and promotions.
  • Uber Sexual Harassment Settlement: $4.4 million to settle claims of sexual harassment and discrimination against female employees.

In Conclusion

The process of negotiating a settlement can be hard and complicated. You can improve your chances of getting the best possible result for your case, though, by learning about the different steps in the process, the common strategies lawyers use, and the things that can change the outcome.

I hope that this blog post has helped you understand how settlement talks work. Feel free to leave a question or message below.


What does a deal mean?

When it comes to the law, a settlement is an agreement between two or more parties that ends a dispute without getting to court. It’s pretty much an agreement made outside of court that ends the civil clash.

Why are agreements a good idea?

  • You can settle the conflict faster: Trials can take months or even years, but settlements can be finished faster. This can help everyone save time and money on court fees.
  • Less uncertainty: Unlike cases, where the outcome is unknown, settlements offer a certain outcome, giving everyone peace of mind and closure.
  • Flexibility: The terms of a settlement can be changed to fit the wants and situations of each party, making it a more flexible option than a court judgment.
  • Privacy: Many settlements are private, which can be good for people who want to keep the facts of their dispute secret.

What are the bad things about settlements?

  • It might not be the best outcome: A settlement might not offer as much money or other help as a court ruling in some situations.
  • Chance of being unfair: If one side has more power in negotiations, the solution might not be fair to the other side.
  • Limited access to evidence: The parties might not be able to see all the evidence they would have at trial, which could change how they negotiate.

When do settlement negotiations happen?

At any point in the legal process, from before a case is filed to right before the trial, talks can take place. Formal talks can sometimes be started by mediation or a court order.

How can I get the best settlement?

Hire a good lawyer, set reasonable goals, be open to compromise, and be patient while the talks go on.

Do I have to accept the first offer I get?

Not at all. You can keep negotiating with the help of your agent until you reach a fair agreement.

Before I agree to a deal, what should I think about?

Talk to your lawyer about the deal in detail, make sure you fully understand the terms and conditions, and make sure you’re happy with the final agreement.

Are settlements kept secret?

Yes, settlement talks are usually kept secret unless both sides agree otherwise.

What takes place if a deal can’t be made?

The case might go to court, where a judge or jury will decide what will happen.

Can I talk to the other person about a deal without a lawyer?

Technically, you could do it on your own, but it’s strongly suggested that you hire a lawyer to protect your rights and make sure you get fair pay.

Related Articles